Mix & Match Discounts
Quantity Discounts


Buy 1 - 3$78.99/Each

You will only be emailed once the product becomes available. We won't add you to our email list or share your data.

  • Made from raw cow's milk and features a fresh, extra-sharp flavor
  • Perfect for sandwiches, specialty pizzas, or garnishing soups
  • Semi-hard consistency that can be cut into cubes, chunks, or slices
  • Wrapped in durable black wax for protection during storage, aging, and shipment
  • Ships refrigerated
UPC Code:400013207401
Shipping:Usually Ships In 1 Business Day
Cheese Type Cheddar
Made in America Yes
Origin Domestic

Package Size12 lb.
Refrigerated Foods Yes
Style Wheel
Texture Semi-Hard & Hard
Type Cheese

Customer questions about this product

When will my refrigerated or frozen food product be shipped?
In order to control the amount of time in transit for these perishable items, they are only shipped on select days of the week based on which shipping method you choose and the transit time to your location.

Ground: Orders ship Monday through Wednesday.
Second Day: Orders ship Monday through Wednesday.
Next Day: Orders ship Monday through Thursday.

Orders placed on or just prior to a holiday could experience a slight delay in shipping.

Frozen and refrigerated items cannot ship in a quantity that requires Common Carrier shipping, as well as cannot be shipped outside of the United States.
Why does my product weigh a different amount than what is listed?
We have provided the nominal, or standard, weight for this product. Due to food preparation procedures, this product’s actual weight might be slightly different than stated.
Ask your own question!


This York Valley Cheese Company white extra sharp cheddar cheese is perfect for sandwiches, specialty pizzas, or garnishing soups. Made with raw cow's milk and featuring a bold, extra sharp cheddar flavor and white color with a dense consistency, this cheese is sure to be a favorite amongst your customers. Its semi-hard consistency can be cut into cubes, chunks, or sliced thin for sandwiches too.

Try grating it over top of a warm omelette to achieve a delicious melted texture that adds a tasty, creamy finish to your cooked product. Or consider slicing it and serving alongside fresh cut ham on white bread to create a classic deli sandwich. This sharp cheddar cheese wheel comes sealed in durable black wax to keep it protected during shipment. Regardless of whether you're filling out a charcuterie board to pair with a winter stout at a catering event or party, or topping an award winning sandwich, this cheese is sure to be a crowd pleaser.

Located in the quiet town of Hallam, Pennsylvania, York Valley Cheese Company products ensure small-town excellence that has been passed down through four generations of cheese curing experts. Founded in 1925 by M.R. Druck, Mr. Druck began selling the cheeses in farmers markets; by word of mouth, he began attracting more and more customers seeking his delectable cheese and soon after, his company took off! They make all-natural Grade A cheese by using only rich whole milk and a specialized curing process perfected by an expert Wisconsin cheese maker. With a variety of cheeses, York Valley Cheese Company provides the wholesome flavor and quality your customers are looking for.

  • Refrigerated Food

    Refrigerated Food

    This item is shipped refrigerated. You will need to ensure this item is stored at 41 degrees Fahrenheit or cooler.

  • Made in America

    Made in America

    This item was made in the United States of America.

Resources and Downloads

A PDF viewer is required to view this product's information. Download Adobe Acrobat software

Overall User Rating:

Replace Heading Here

4.2 stars from 5 reviews


People Talk About:

cheese sharp wheel extra freeze more buy cheddar cut dry

Customer Reviews


Would not call this extra sharp. The cheese is fairly sharp and the texture is excellent. I tried to freeze a quarter and the cheese turned crumbled - do not freeze this cheese (not a mark agains the product, should not really freeze cheese.) Will order again and perhaps keep one for aging. Slices well, easy to cut, and the size is perfect for us.

Erik from Nøff Nøff BBQ on 03/21/2021

We must have gotten a better run than some of the other reviewers on here, because ours was definitely very sharp, and not dry at all....it was excellent. We cut it up into 6 sections and gave 4 of them away to family and friends and everyone of them has since contacted me asking for the name of the company. Getting ready to buy another wheel right now, just hope it's as good as the last one.

Paul C. from Paul C. on 12/15/2020

Tillamook it isn't. The cheese is of good quality, and we used it all up eventually. Thing is, it's hardly 'extra sharp". 'Medium' is more like it--great for cheese sauce or macaroni, but not what we were looking for for toasted cheese recipes. If they billed it as 'Medium' or even 'Sharp', I'd give it more stars.

Philip H. on 10/31/2020

Thank you for your feedback! We’re sorry you did not prefer this product. For recommendations, please contact our Customer Solutions team.

WebstaurantStore Customer Solutions

We like the fact that this cheese came in a wheel. The flavor was not sharp and the cheese in our wheel was rather hard and dry. Having said this we are using the cheese for grilled cheese and smoked turkey sandwiches and all together the sandwich is wonderful with this cheese melted into it. Perhaps our wheel was replaced accidentally with a mild cheddar.

Maureen G. from Agency on 05/27/2020

We discovered this cheese in a town near my home called Waterville in PA. It’s an exceptional Extra Sharp Cheddar with a smooth taste to go along with its lovely sharpness. We’ve found its best if left out to become room temperature. We will buy more of this again and again. The people in Lancaster know how to craft a great aromatic and robust cheese. I was especially pleased to find it here on the WebstaurantStore.... Thanks

William J. from Wjm on 10/19/2019

Leave a review of this product!

If you've used this product, log in and leave a review to tell us and other customers what you thought about it.

Login or Register