Check at least 2 products

Compare Products: Check up to four products with to see a side-by-side comparison

× Remove All Filters
York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 12 lb. Mini Wheel of White Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese in Black WaxYork Valley Cheese Company Druck's 12 lb. Mini Wheel of White Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese in Black Wax
York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 12 lb. Mini Wheel of White Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese in Black Wax

#875774021

From$54.75/Each

1 - 2 3+
$56.99$54.75

Notify me when this
product is back in stock:

York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 12 lb. Mini Wheel of Yellow Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese in Red WaxYork Valley Cheese Company Druck's 12 lb. Mini Wheel of Yellow Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese in Red Wax
York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 12 lb. Mini Wheel of Yellow Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese in Red Wax

#875774020

From$54.75/Each

1 - 2 3+
$56.99$54.75

AMPI 5 lb. White Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseAMPI 5 lb. White Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
AMPI 5 lb. White Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774101C

From$38.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$39.99$38.50

Cabot Premium Naturally Aged Mild Cheddar Cheese - 10 lb. Solid Block
Cabot Premium Naturally Aged Mild Cheddar Cheese - 10 lb. Solid Block

#875774072

From$35.00/Case

1 - 2 3+
$36.49$35.00

Cabot Vermont Sharp White Cheddar Cheese 10 lb. BlockCabot Vermont Sharp White Cheddar Cheese 10 lb. Block
Cabot Vermont Sharp White Cheddar Cheese 10 lb. Block

#875774068

From$57.00/Each

1 - 2 3+
$59.49$57.00

York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 3 lb. Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Gem WheelYork Valley Cheese Company Druck's 3 lb. Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Gem Wheel
York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 3 lb. Sharp Yellow Cheddar Cheese Gem Wheel

#875559824

From$14.06/Each

1 - 2 3+
$14.49$14.06

AMPI 5 lb. Yellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseAMPI 5 lb. Yellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
AMPI 5 lb. Yellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774103C

From$38.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$39.99$38.50

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Buffalo Wing Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Buffalo Wing Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Buffalo Wing Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774181

From$50.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$52.49$50.50

Collier's 5.5 lb. Powerful Welsh Cheddar Cheese Block - 2/CaseCollier's 5.5 lb. Powerful Welsh Cheddar Cheese Block - 2/Case
Collier's 5.5 lb. Powerful Welsh Cheddar Cheese Block - 2/Case

#875CLLCHED11

From$86.73/Case

1 - 2 3+
$88.99$86.73

Guinness Cheddar 5.5 lb. Stout Beer Infused Cheese Block - 2/CaseGuinness Cheddar 5.5 lb. Stout Beer Infused Cheese Block - 2/Case
Guinness Cheddar 5.5 lb. Stout Beer Infused Cheese Block - 2/Case

#875GCHED11

From$89.06/Case

1 - 2 3+
$92.99$89.06

Notify me when this
product is back in stock:

AMPI 5 lb. Yellow Mild Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseAMPI 5 lb. Yellow Mild Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
AMPI 5 lb. Yellow Mild Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774107C

From$36.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$37.99$36.50

AMPI 5 lb. White Mild Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseAMPI 5 lb. White Mild Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
AMPI 5 lb. White Mild Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774108C

From$36.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$37.99$36.50

Notify me when this
product is back in stock:

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Buffalo Wing Flavored New York Cheddar CheeseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Buffalo Wing Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Buffalo Wing Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese

#999774181

$27.49/Each

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Steakhouse Onion Flavored New York Cheddar CheeseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Steakhouse Onion Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Steakhouse Onion Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese

#999774185

$27.49/Each

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Horseradish Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Horseradish Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Horseradish Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774182

From$50.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$52.49$50.50

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Pepperoni Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Pepperoni Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Pepperoni Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774180

From$50.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$52.49$50.50

Yellow Mild Cheddar Cheese - 10 lb. Solid BlockYellow Mild Cheddar Cheese - 10 lb. Solid Block
Yellow Mild Cheddar Cheese - 10 lb. Solid Block

#875774129

From$31.36/Case

1 - 2 3+
$32.49$31.36

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Pepperoni Flavored New York Cheddar CheeseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Pepperoni Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Pepperoni Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese

#999774180

$27.49/Each

Collier's 7 oz. Powerful Welsh Cheddar Cheese Wedge - 12/CaseCollier's 7 oz. Powerful Welsh Cheddar Cheese Wedge - 12/Case
Collier's 7 oz. Powerful Welsh Cheddar Cheese Wedge - 12/Case

#875CHDWLSH7Z

From$39.81/Case

1 - 2 3+
$41.49$39.81

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Horseradish Flavored New York Cheddar CheeseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Horseradish Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Horseradish Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese

#999774182

$27.49/Each

Biery 2.25 lb. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese - 4/CaseBiery 2.25 lb. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese - 4/Case
Biery 2.25 lb. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese - 4/Case

#875774151C

From$37.01/Case

1 - 2 3+
$38.49$37.01

Oak Shade Sharp White Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 8/CaseOak Shade Sharp White Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 8/Case
Oak Shade Sharp White Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 8/Case

#875774032C

From$210.00/Case

1 - 2 3+
$218.49$210.00

Old Quebec 5 oz. Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 12/CaseOld Quebec 5 oz. Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 12/Case
Old Quebec 5 oz. Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 12/Case

#875774004C

From$55.63/Case

1 - 2 3+
$57.99$55.63

Notify me when this
product is back in stock:

Old Quebec Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 2/CaseOld Quebec Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 2/Case
Old Quebec Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 2/Case

#875774005C

From$113.82/Case

1 - 2 3+
$118.49$113.82

Notify me when this
product is back in stock:

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Steakhouse Onion Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Steakhouse Onion Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Steakhouse Onion Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774185

From$50.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$52.49$50.50

York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 38 lb. Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cheese WheelYork Valley Cheese Company Druck's 38 lb. Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cheese Wheel
York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 38 lb. Extra Sharp White Cheddar Cheese Wheel

#875774018

From$186.68/Each

1 - 2 3+
$194.49$186.68

Old Quebec Vintage Cheddar 7 Years Aged Super Sharp Reserve Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 2/CaseOld Quebec Vintage Cheddar 7 Years Aged Super Sharp Reserve Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 2/Case
Old Quebec Vintage Cheddar 7 Years Aged Super Sharp Reserve Cheddar Cheese 5 lb. Solid Block - 2/Case

#875774006C

From$161.20/Case

1 - 2 3+
$166.99$161.20

5 lb. Habanero Cheddar Cheese Block - 8/Case5 lb. Habanero Cheddar Cheese Block - 8/Case
5 lb. Habanero Cheddar Cheese Block - 8/Case

#875774041C

From$198.72/Case

1 - 2 3+
$202.49$198.72

Black Diamond 5 lb. Grand Reserve Premium Extra Sharp Aged Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseBlack Diamond 5 lb. Grand Reserve Premium Extra Sharp Aged Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
Black Diamond 5 lb. Grand Reserve Premium Extra Sharp Aged Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875CWCA020

From$131.13/Case

1 - 2 3+
$136.49$131.13

Carr Valley Cheese Company 5 lb. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese Loaf - 2/CaseCarr Valley Cheese Company 5 lb. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese Loaf - 2/Case
Carr Valley Cheese Company 5 lb. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese Loaf - 2/Case

#875CAR1026

From$61.31/Case

1 - 2 3+
$62.99$61.31

Carr Valley Cheese Company 7 oz. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese - 12/CaseCarr Valley Cheese Company 7 oz. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese - 12/Case
Carr Valley Cheese Company 7 oz. Hickory Smoked Cheddar Cheese - 12/Case

#875CAR3037

From$42.81/Case

1 - 2 3+
$44.99$42.81

Oak Shade Cheese 40 lb. Sharp White Cheddar CheeseOak Shade Cheese 40 lb. Sharp White Cheddar Cheese
Oak Shade Cheese 40 lb. Sharp White Cheddar Cheese

#875774031

From$195.00/Each

1 - 2 3+
$202.99$195.00

Old Quebec Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. BlockOld Quebec Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. Block
Old Quebec Vintage Cheddar 3 Years Aged Super Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. Block

#875774002

From$381.80/Each

1 - 2 3+
$398.49$381.80

White Mild Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. BlockWhite Mild Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. Block
White Mild Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. Block

#875774105

From$124.38/Each

1 - 2 3+
$128.99$124.38

Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Roasted Garlic Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/CaseYancey's Fancy 5 lb. Roasted Garlic Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case
Yancey's Fancy 5 lb. Roasted Garlic Flavored New York Cheddar Cheese - 2/Case

#875774184

From$50.50/Case

1 - 2 3+
$52.49$50.50

Yellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. Solid BlockYellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. Solid Block
Yellow Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 40 lb. Solid Block

#875774012

From$137.50/Each

1 - 2 3+
$144.49$137.50

York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 22 lb. Daisy Clear Wax Sharp Colored Cheddar Cheese Flat WheelYork Valley Cheese Company Druck's 22 lb. Daisy Clear Wax Sharp Colored Cheddar Cheese Flat Wheel
York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 22 lb. Daisy Clear Wax Sharp Colored Cheddar Cheese Flat Wheel

#875559803

From$109.18/Each

1 - 2 3+
$112.99$109.18

York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 40 lb. Extra Sharp Golden Yellow Cheddar Cheese WheelYork Valley Cheese Company Druck's 40 lb. Extra Sharp Golden Yellow Cheddar Cheese Wheel
York Valley Cheese Company Druck's 40 lb. Extra Sharp Golden Yellow Cheddar Cheese Wheel

#875559802

From$191.50/Each

1 - 2 3+
$198.99$191.50

If you're wondering where to buy block cheddar cheese, we have a large selection of block cheddar cheese for sale at the lowest prices.