Check at least 2 products

Compare Products: Check up to four products with to see a side-by-side comparison

Golden Barrel 5 Gallon (38 lb.) Coconut OilGolden Barrel 5 Gallon (38 lb.) Coconut Oil

From$51.21/Each

Reg.3 - 11 Lots of 12
$52.99$52.41$51.21

Golden Barrel Organic Cane Sugar - 50 lb.Golden Barrel Organic Cane Sugar - 50 lb.

From$39.05/Each

Reg.5 - 9 Lots of 10
$42.49$39.76$39.05

Golden Barrel Light Corn Syrup - 5 GallonGolden Barrel Light Corn Syrup - 5 Gallon

From$33.73/Each

Reg.3 - 11 Lots of 12Lots of 36
$35.99$35.39$34.56$33.73

Golden Barrel 5 Gallon Sulfur-Free Blackstrap MolassesGolden Barrel 5 Gallon Sulfur-Free Blackstrap Molasses

From$28.14/Each

Reg.3 - 11 Lots of 12Lots of 36
$29.99$29.31$28.61$28.14

Golden Barrel 50 lb. Raw SugarGolden Barrel 50 lb. Raw Sugar

From$30.90/Bag

Reg.5 - 9 Lots of 10
$31.99$31.42$30.90

Golden Barrel 5 Gallon Corn SyrupGolden Barrel 5 Gallon Corn Syrup

From$32.04/Each

12+
$33.49$32.04

Shank's Premium 1 Gallon Pure Vanilla ExtractShank's Premium 1 Gallon Pure Vanilla Extract

From$299.52/Each

Reg.Lots of 4Lots of 12
$308.99$304.20$299.52

Golden Barrel 1 Gallon Sulfur-Free Blackstrap Molasses - 4/Case

From$23.52/Case

1 - 2 3+
$24.49$23.52

Golden Barrel 50 lb. Light Brown SugarGolden Barrel 50 lb. Light Brown Sugar

From$30.64/Bag

5+Lots of 10
$31.99$31.16$30.64

Shank's 32 oz. White Imitation Vanilla

From$6.38/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$6.89$6.38

Golden Barrel Organic Light Brown Sugar - 50 lb.Golden Barrel Organic Light Brown Sugar - 50 lb.

From$43.70/Each

Reg.5 - 9 Lots of 10
$47.49$44.46$43.70

Golden Barrel 50 lb. Dark Brown SugarGolden Barrel 50 lb. Dark Brown Sugar

From$30.64/Bag

5+Lots of 10
$31.99$31.16$30.64

Notify me when this
product is back in stock:

Shank's 1 Gallon Fauxnilla Natural Imitation VanillaShank's 1 Gallon Fauxnilla Natural Imitation Vanilla

From$64.13/Each

Reg.Lots of 4
$66.49$64.13

Shank's 32 oz. Organic Vanilla ExtractShank's 32 oz. Organic Vanilla Extract

From$98.63/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$99.99$98.63

Golden Barrel 96 oz. (6 lb.) Coconut OilGolden Barrel 96 oz. (6 lb.) Coconut Oil

From$8.78/Each

Reg.Lots of 6
$9.19$8.78

Shank's 1 Gallon Imitation VanillaShank's 1 Gallon Imitation Vanilla

From$18.10/Each

Reg.Lots of 4
$19.49$18.10

Shank's 8 oz. Pure Lemon Extract

From$4.98/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$5.19$4.98

Shank's 32 oz. Pure Peppermint Extract

From$14.93/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$15.49$14.93

Shank's 32 oz. Organic Almond Extract

From$27.44/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$29.49$27.44

Golden Barrel 1 Gallon Sulfur-Free Supreme Baking Molasses - 4/CaseGolden Barrel 1 Gallon Sulfur-Free Supreme Baking Molasses - 4/Case

From$31.44/Case

1 - 2 3+
$32.99$31.44

Shank's Premium 16 oz. Pure Vanilla ExtractShank's Premium 16 oz. Pure Vanilla Extract

From$38.65/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$39.99$38.65

Golden Barrel 1 Qt. Sulfur-Free Blackstrap Molasses - 12/CaseGolden Barrel 1 Qt. Sulfur-Free Blackstrap Molasses - 12/Case

From$24.90/Case

1 - 2 3+
$25.99$24.90

Shank's 4 oz. Vanilla Bean PasteShank's 4 oz. Vanilla Bean Paste

From$16.07/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$16.49$16.07

Shank's 32 oz. Imitation Coconut

From$14.93/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$15.49$14.93

Golden Barrel 32 oz. Butter Flavored Coconut Oil - 12/CaseGolden Barrel 32 oz. Butter Flavored Coconut Oil - 12/Case

From$42.42/Case

1 - 2 3+
$43.99$42.42

Shank's 32 oz. Natural and Artificial Maple FlavorShank's 32 oz. Natural and Artificial Maple Flavor

From$14.93/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$15.49$14.93

Shank's 8 oz. Imitation Butter

From$4.98/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$5.19$4.98

Golden Barrel 5 lb. Funnel Cake Mix - 6/Case

From$28.60/Case

1 - 2 3+
$29.99$28.60

Domino 10X Confectioners Sugar - 50 lb.Domino 10X Confectioners Sugar - 50 lb.

From$29.16/Each

50+
$29.16

Shank's 32 oz. Imitation Almond

From$13.27/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$14.49$13.27

Golden Barrel 1 Qt. Light Corn Syrup Blend - 12/CaseGolden Barrel 1 Qt. Light Corn Syrup Blend - 12/Case

From$31.44/Case

1 - 2 3+
$32.99$31.44

Golden Barrel 32 oz. Coconut Oil - 12/CaseGolden Barrel 32 oz. Coconut Oil - 12/Case

From$41.69/Case

1 - 2 3+
$43.49$41.69

Shank's 16 oz. Imitation VanillaShank's 16 oz. Imitation Vanilla

From$3.30/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$3.59$3.30

Shank's 32 oz. Organic Lemon ExtractShank's 32 oz. Organic Lemon Extract

From$36.75/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$39.49$36.75

Golden Barrel 1 Qt. Sulfur-Free Supreme Baking Molasses - 12/CaseGolden Barrel 1 Qt. Sulfur-Free Supreme Baking Molasses - 12/Case

From$32.14/Case

1 - 2 3+
$33.49$32.14

Golden Barrel 90/10 Creme Fondant - 50 lb.Golden Barrel 90/10 Creme Fondant - 50 lb.

From$31.80/Each

1 - 2 3+
$32.99$31.80

Shank's 8 oz. White Imitation Vanilla

From$2.27/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$2.49$2.27

Shank's 8 oz. Pure Orange Extract

From$4.98/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$5.19$4.98

Shank's 32 oz. Organic Orange ExtractShank's 32 oz. Organic Orange Extract

From$26.99/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$28.99$26.99

Shank's 32 oz. American Oak Extract

From$10.53/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$11.49$10.53

Shank's 8 oz. Pure Anise Extract

From$4.98/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$5.19$4.98

Golden Barrel 32 oz. Coconut OilGolden Barrel 32 oz. Coconut Oil

$3.89/Each

Shank's 8 oz. Pure Spearmint Extract

From$4.98/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$5.19$4.98

Shank's 32 oz. Organic Peppermint Extract

From$34.65/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$36.99$34.65

Shank's 8 oz. Imitation Almond

From$4.24/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$4.89$4.24

Shank's 8 oz. Imitation Coconut

From$4.98/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$5.19$4.98

Shank's 32 oz. Organic Turmeric ExtractShank's 32 oz. Organic Turmeric Extract

From$17.03/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$17.49$17.03

Golden Barrel 1 Qt. Corn Syrup   - 12/Case

From$26.97/Case

1 - 2 3+
$27.99$26.97

Shank's 8 oz. Natural and Artificial Maple FlavorShank's 8 oz. Natural and Artificial Maple Flavor

From$4.98/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$5.19$4.98

Shank's 16 oz. Fauxnilla Natural Imitation VanillaShank's 16 oz. Fauxnilla Natural Imitation Vanilla

From$9.18/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$9.59$9.18

Shank's 8 oz. Pure Peppermint Extract

From$4.98/Each

Reg.Lots of 12
$5.19$4.98

Golden Barrel 80/20 Creme Fondant - 50 lb.Golden Barrel 80/20 Creme Fondant - 50 lb.

From$30.60/Each

1 - 2 3+
$31.99$30.60

Golden Barrel 1.5 lb. Shoofly Pie Mix with Syrup - 12/CaseGolden Barrel 1.5 lb. Shoofly Pie Mix with Syrup - 12/Case

From$29.28/Case

1 - 2 3+
$30.49$29.28

Golden Barrel 2.75 lb. Shoofly Cake Mix with Syrup - 12/CaseGolden Barrel 2.75 lb. Shoofly Cake Mix with Syrup - 12/Case

From$29.90/Case

1 - 2 3+
$30.49$29.90

We have a large selection of Pennsylvania Dutch baking ingredients, such as flavor extracts, molasses, and raw sugar. You can use these products to create delicious desserts to add to your menu, or you can place your baked goods in a display case near your cash register to boost your impulse sales. As an added bonus, all of these products come from Lancaster County, making them authentic ingredients for making classic Pennsylvania Dutch dishes. For more baking products, check out our fondant, baking toppings, and pie filling. If you're wondering where to buy PA Dutch baking ingredients, we have a large selection of PA Dutch baking ingredients for sale at the lowest prices.