Reviews for 5 lb. Sugar Cookie Mix

Was not impressed with these at all. Unfortunately, when following the directions to "just add water", these are not very good. We made them according to the package exactly, and allowed several people to try them for quality and consistency, and every person said they did not meet their expectations of a sugar cookie. Tried another, local, just add water mix, and the quality was superior to this. Would not recommend to anyone.

I have great ideas for this cookie mix, adding some fruit filling to make thumb print cookies, decorating some with colored sugar an sprinkles, and even putting into a cookie cup pan and inserting mini peant butter cups into the centers ...this will be a real time saver too!!

This mix makes a great base for cookies and really all you do is add water. I tend to add additional ingredients to add more flavor, so think again of it as a base.

Nice easy sugar cookies. Not good for rolled out cookies as it doesn't hold it's shape well without puffing but sprinkle a little cinnamon sugar on top and it makes a wonderful snickerdoodle.

I purchased this mix with the intention of making a Snickerdoodle. Took me a couple of test batches to get it down but I have had customers telling me they are the best they've ever had. I do my batches using 3# of mix - 2 tsp of Cream of Tartar, 1 TBSP Cinnamon, and 9.1 oz of water. My cookies are 5"+ in diameter so to get them to cook evenly I press them down. The dough was sticky so I learned to press them into the cinnamon sugar so they don't stick. I don't have a full kitchen at the shop - I have gotten it approved from the Health Department to use a table top convection oven and I do small "artisan" batches. But now I'm selling about 15 dozen cookies per week and 8 dozen muffins. These do freeze Read More

I do not recommend this product. It isn't good

This was an interesting buy. Tried it and didn't like it. The cookies baked very dry and tasted like a cookie that was stale. I don't recommend. The only way to make a sugar cookie is from scratch and then roll it out.

I love the ease in using this product. I added some of my own touches, but the mix is a great base. I added sprinkles and vanilla extract for Celebration Cookies; added butter and vanilla extract and rolled a batch in cinnamon sugar for Snickerdoddles. The price is GREAT too for the amount of product.

I bake from scratch, but decided to try this mi. I love this product! I can add all sorts of flavors and candy, etc. to it to make even more amazing cookies. I am thrilled I was smart enough to try this mix. I will be buying this again and agai .

I bought this to save time in making them from scratch ! Unfortunately, there is too much baking soda in the mixture.. They taste too bitter once cooked.. I tried to even it out a little by adding some extra ingredients, but it just would not take away the bitterness.. Nice size for the amount, and maybe some people like that taste of baking soda, I unfortunately do not..... I will still be giving 5 stars because it was a great deal for the amount you get, its just a matter of taste, and I cannot fault the company for that !

Not your typical sugar cookie mix, the cookies were very dense and almost cake like. Flavor was a nice light vanilla blend but i would not recommended or be repurchasing this particular product in the future.

this cookie mix makes delicious and soft sugar cookies that stay soft for a couple days. it’s also really easy to use and the directions are. easy to follow.

A delicious quality sugar cookie mix and perfect for making warm, soft cookies for our bake shop. A great base for mixing in chocolate chips or sprinkles.

Very yummy and easy to bake. Just add water and mix. What more can you ask for. We ice these cookies soon out of the oven.

The sugar cookie mix is delicious and great for our cutout, decorated sugar cookies. We love the great mix and the price is the best.

The Case of 6 bags of sugar cookie mix is great for catering events or other social functions where a classic, conventional cookie is needed. These also just need water to be prepared.

Quick sugar cookie when you just don’t have time to make from scratch. I was very impressed with the quality and taste! Amazing! I added sugar to mine bc I put in the oven!

A nice sugar cookie mix that is great for making our cut out cookies. They roll out well and cook up perfectly. Terrific with icing.

This is an easy to use product that just needs water to be added. Resulting cookies taste great but you might need to test out different cooking times and temperatures for the best results.

The Old Tyme Mill Sugae cookie mix just need to add water and bake. Simple instructions, great tasting cookies that will cater well in commercial settings such as hotels, restaurants, parties.

It is always best to buy your products in bulk especially if you own a restaurant. This stuff makes great sugar cookies quickly and at a great price.

A very tasty and easy to make mix at a wonderful price. The sugar cookie mix is great and makes a great mix for cutting out Christmas cookies.

This cookie mix is easy to follow and makes such a wonderful textured cookie or cookie cake. It will have your entire business smelling like fantastic cookies. Great product.

This mix is great! It makes approx. 100 cookies and I can change them into anything I want such as Salted Caramel Cookies. The next best thing is that I do not have to make them all at once I can just make what I need and put the rest away until its needed! Great buy

Just add water. It can't get any easier. We received lots of compliments on the cookies and everyone was satisfied. We added a little more water than called for but did not use cookie cutters.

The over all flavor of this product was good, but it turned out much fluffier than you would expect a cookie would be. Given that it had much of a cake texture, we ended up using it as just that, we created many different sweet cupcakes and muffins with this mix.

Our Sugar Cookie minute cake is one our most popular, it so much fun with sprinkles and sugar on top. Every kid and kid at heart loves a good sugar cookie.

Didn't get to taste these cookies but they looked good! Will definitely be purchasing these again and will be trying out the different flavors that are offered.

These basic cookies are good all on their own or to use as a base for cookies with more ingredients, whichever ones you may desire.

A good basic cookie mix. Being that you only need water makes it quick to make. Plus you can add sprinkles or chips if you want to add you own little twist to them.

The day this was delivered, my cousins decided they wanted cookies. When they came to raid my pantry for a packet of mix (the supermarket kind), I told them they were in luck - I had a brand new bag of sugar cookie mix. Even though the description clearly states that the instructions are on the bag, the bag was competent blank. No temperature or time instructions, no ratio of water to mix - NOTHING. After looking it up on the site, I weighed out the right portion of mix and water/vanilla extract mix, and told them that the fee for my supplies was I wanted a few of the cookies. When I asked later where my cookies were, In their words, "the cookies sucked, we went out for donuts". Apparently the dog wouldn't eat them either.

5lb Sugar Cookie Mix Today I wanted to try some of these baking items, so I took a run at this mix, first thing first this one was really easy to make literally just add water, and it still taste good, esp since I do my own cookies from scratch

Meh. These are so-so, but in no way compare to my homemade sugar cookies. My customers would know the difference immediately. Not a win for me.

I wanted to give this mix a try just because of the amazing price and the ease of mixing and baking them. They were ok. No better than your store bought sugar cookie, but not as good as the mix I was previously using. Can't win them all.

Surprising how good these taste. my mother is my cookie baker and has baked sugar cookies my entire life. She even liked this brand. very easy and convenient.

Wow really fast just added water an mixed simple and fast. Our youth group made these for our rib dinner . Made a lot of really moist delicious cookies. Big hit

This 5 lb cookie mix is a very good and affordable way to be able to serve our customers with home baked cookies. They love them!

This was my first time using sugar cookie mix it came out perfect and I use different style of cookie cutters and the taste was actually wonderful

Delicious cookies that are very easy to make, and very enjoyable to eat. Don't tell Mom, but these cookies are actually better then the ones she makes.

I have to say, I usually would much rather make my own cookies, but this mix is fantastic. The taste is superb and the quality is, as well. I'm just a home cook, but I would highly recommend this product to anyone who needs to make a lot of cookies at one time!! My only issue with the mix is that the bag doesn't give more directions on how much water to use. If I want to make a dozen cookies rather than 5lbs, I have to calculate out the water and inevitably it's wrong (but it doesn't affect the taste, just the density!)