Reviews for REESE'S All-Natural Peanut Butter Sauce Jar 4.5 lb.

We ordered this by accident, but it still tasted amazing! Easy to spread and put in desserts or on sandwiches!

Great flavor!

The taste is good, but it is so hard to use. It needs mixed and it is settled way too much. Won’t buy again.

While it is really tasty, it's extremely thick and hard to blend back together again. We tried using out immersion blender and it actually stalled on us! I got just enough blended up for what we needed. I'll figure something out soon enough because this tastes really good!

We use this in our ice cream trailer. It is delicious in milkshakes or as a sundae. The oil is separated when we receive it so we scrape it into our kitchen aid mixer to stir it,then pour it back into the original container to use it.

We used this for a drizzle topping for our Reese's Frappe and it tasted just like the inside of a Reese's. We also drizzle some inside of a hot cup for Reese lattes. It is a sauce and flows perfect in a small nozzle drizzle bottle. You have to mix well the first time you open it, but after that it is perfect.

As others have mentioned, the oil separates. What you are left with is hard peanut butter on the bottom and oil on the top. This means you must mix it to use it and that is a major hassle. And by hassle I mean 10 minutes with a strong immersion blender or into your commercial food processor not simply stirring with a spoon. I got this because it's all natural and we serve organic ice cream. However, I can't find any difference in the ingredients. Not worth the effort for us. If you've got time to kill, it may be great for you. Going back to regular version.

very watery, doesn't really taste like real peanut butter. i don't recommend buying it. i would stick with other brands., its very hard to mix and the container is bad

We used this PB first and the natural aspect meant that the oil separated from the peanut butter and it was a hassle to mix it up when we received it. We swapped to the regular Reese's peanut butter sauce and it's much easer to use.

Our customers LOVE the taste of this peanut butter and prefer it over the non brand selection we offered. This will need to be stirred after sitting to ensure the right distribution, otherwise the oil is at the top and the thickness is at the bottom. Be sure to store in a cool place, can sometimes get runny if stored in the sun. Overall great product, have purchased multiple times.

Reese's all natural peanut butter sauce has the best texture to drizzle onto our açaí bowls. The taste is amazing and the consistency is perfect.

I love this peanut butter. It’s great for everything sundaes. Milk shakes. Baking. It’s easy to use. All around the best peanut butter. If your looking for a great tasting peanut butter this is it by far

This peanut butter is one of the most popular toppings at our ice cream shop. Its the perfect texture! It does require frequent stirring before use. I love that the ingredients are pretty simple too. Definitely a great product.

Heaven in a jar! If you like peanut butter you need to try this kind. This reeses all natural peanut butt is so good. Amazong flavor and it is actually at a decent price here. And 4.5 lb tub will last us quite a while!

Love love love this peanut butter. It’s fantastic to cook, bake or just eat it! It’s smooth and not oily. I would give this 10 stars!

Holy cow!! This jar is perfect for peanut butter lovers. It holds almost 5 lbs of deliciousness. I like that it is all natural too

A super fresh and tasty all natural peanut butter that is smooth and delicious. A great butter to use with our bagels cream cheese spreads. A great taste and price for our shop.

Between peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, my wife’s baking, and using it as a dipping sauce for apples and celery – we go through a lot of peanut butter in this house. This is a wonderful, all-natural peanut butter that you can feel good about eating.

I searched for a natural peanut butter that was also a decent price. I found this peanut butter after lots of research. I love that the ingredients are simple. It's a great consistency to work with. When you first take the lid off the unopened jar, it is sealed tight for freshness. Once you take off the seal, the peanut butter is separated as most natural peanut butters are. After a little bit of mixing, your peanut butter will be smooth and taste great!

The REESE'S all natural peanut butter is tasteful and spreads great. A nice breakfast topping for my toast and bagel. Love the great brand of Reese's.

I love the great taste and quality of the REESE'S all natural peanut butter. It is great for making our peanut butter cup milkshakes. I love the great consistency and its so easy to spread.

When I first bought a jar of this, I had no idea that it would go as quickly as it did. I had to reorder a bunch of these peanut butter jars within a few weeks. It is delicious!

With this 4.5-pound jar, there is so much Reese's all natural peanut butter goodness to use. Yes we do spread it on top of cheesecakes, ice cream and cupcakes. We also use it as ingredient to make peanut salad dressing. The consistency is just right and the taste is awesome.

Reese’s all natural peanut butter. A jug that weighs 4.5 pounds! It has to be mixed well and it then can be used in many different dishes.

A really nice creamy peanut butter from REESE'S that tastes great. A perfect addition to our smoothies for extra protein. The peanut butter is also great for making our peanut butter frosting.

This is the most delicious peanut butter sauce. It goes perfectly in ice cream and cheesecake and in cookies and cakes. You won't find this in any store and this site has the best price to buy in bulk!

This all natural reeses peanut butter is so good. It makes our smoothies very rich and creamy. We buy this product all the time. A+ product.!!

Perfect texture and viscosity for drizzling and dispensing. Love the option for natural peanut butter with the ease of not having to thin it out to make our drizzle. Definitely a staple in our shop!

I can't believe that I found this. Peanut butter is one of my favorite flavors and now I have something to put on vanilla ice cream

Arrived on time and in good condition. Tastes exactly like Reese's! Arrives in an unmixed watery/ goopy mess, so plan on having an egg beater, a cake mixer, something of that sort handy to whip it up into its intended final product.

Husband was so glad to see his Favorite Peanut Butter. It is so difficult to find. Remember, great Peanut Butter has oil. Stir it thoroughly.

Perfect for baking (and that's all). Before we ordered, we called to make sure this was actual peanut butter and not just peanut butter sauce. When we received it, we verified that it was actual peanut butter. After mixing the ingredients together (they had separated), the peanut butter was runnier than we expected. This was perfect for us, since we were baking with it. However, if you're looking for peanut butter to use in a non-baking application, look elsewhere. I wouldn't want this on my sandwich.

The REESE'S All-Natural Peanut Butter is delicious! I use it for ice cream topping and for shakes. I am very happy with my purchase and highly recommend!

I have ordered this in the past and this time got a bad one, however customer service rectified the problem within 3 minutes. Flavor warranted the fifth star!!

Great flavor and texture, I use this to make my peanut butter filling and peanut butter frosting for my cakes, this is also a great value.

When I originally bought this product I thought it was actual peanut butter. This products is NOT peanut butter but a peanut butter sauce. It has been excellent however in my morning protein shakes!

This is just Peanut butter, not reesses filling as i thought, but still great to use in baking and sandwiches. And you get 4.5 pounds of it for a good price.

It tastes like premium peanut butter. It is all natural which is an added bonus. It is a big jar but will go quickly due to great taste.