Substitutes for Corn Syrup

Last updated on Nov 12, 2026
Val Goodrich

Whether you’re taking corn syrup off your menu, dealing with a supply gap, or just ran out mid-prep, the eight substitutes below can keep your recipes on track. Corn syrup is a glucose-based syrup that interferes with sugar crystals as they form, which keeps caramel and chocolate sauces, ice cream bases, and brownies smooth instead of grainy, and it’s why it’s a staple in candy making. Not every alternative has the same makeup, and sucrose-heavy options like maple syrup won’t stop crystallization the way corn syrup does. Read each entry before swapping one into a batch, especially for candy or caramel, where the wrong substitute can turn a smooth product gritty.

Click below to check out the different corn syrup substitutes:

Corn Syrup Substitute

When substituting corn syrup, know that corn syrup’s sweetness level is around 77 Brix (a scale used to measure the dissolved sugar content of a liquid solution). Because corn syrup has a high Brix number, you’ll want to use a sweetener that has a matching (or similar) Brix number if you’d like the substitute to be just as sweet. However, finding a matching Brix number is not always necessary if you just want a corn syrup substitute that will mimic the other properties that corn syrup lends. Check out these corn syrup substitutes to use in your recipes.

1. Brown Rice Syrup

pouring brown rice syrup over granola in a bowl

Brown rice syrup is one of the best substitutes for corn syrup. Its Brix level is at 78, making it almost at the same sweetness level as corn syrup’s 77. It also prevents crystallization and can withstand candy-making temperatures. It also has a light brown color (making it a great light corn syrup substitute) and has the same viscosity as corn syrup. The only downside is the difference in taste. This syrup is made from rice starch that has a lightly toasted rice flavor that may not be suitable for all corn syrup applications.

  • Brown Rice Syrup Brix Level: 78 degrees Brix
  • Best As a Corn Syrup Substitute For: Candy, marshmallows, fudge, baked goods, and granola
  • How to Substitute Brown Rice Syrup for Corn Syrup: Use a 1:1 ratio by volume. It can taste a little less sweet than corn syrup, so test a small batch before scaling up. It’s thick, so warm the container slightly to make pouring and measuring easier on a busy line.
  • Brown Rice Syrup Taste Profile: Mild, nutty, and toasty, often compared to butterscotch. It suits granola bars, brittle, fudge, and chocolate and works as a light corn syrup substitute where a toasty flavor is welcome.

2. Maple Syrup

wooden spoon and dish of maple syrup with leaves in the background

Maple syrup is another corn syrup substitute you can try out and is most likely in your pantry right now. Keep in mind, maple syrup is not the best corn syrup substitute for candy as it has a lower viscosity, different flavor, and a Brix level that falls between 66 and 68 (not as sweet as corn syrup). However, it can still be used for desserts like sauces, cookies, and quick bread! Plus, maple syrup comes in many different hues, so choose the best maple syrup grade for your corn syrup substitute.

  • Maple Syrup Brix Level: 66-68 degrees Brix
  • Best As a Corn Syrup Substitute For: Sauces, cookies, and quick bread
  • How to Substitute Maple Syrup for Corn Syrup: Use a 1:1 ratio in sauces, glazes, cookies, and quick breads. It’s thinner than corn syrup, so glazes and fillings may need extra reduction time, and baked goods will brown faster, so check them early. Don’t rely on it where crystallization control matters, such as caramel or candy, because it’s mostly sucrose.
  • Maple Syrup Taste Profile: Woody with caramel notes. Golden and amber grades are mild enough to replace light corn syrup, while dark grades replace dark corn syrup.

3. Agave

pouring agave from a measuring cup into a bowl

Agave is another corn syrup substitute, especially for light corn syrup! Agave is fairly mild in flavor so it can work in many different dishes without altering the taste other than making it sweeter. It’s a 1:1 swap for corn syrup and can be used in pies and sauces, but is not suitable for candy making. Just note that some agaves are sweeter than others!

  • Agave Brix Level: 67-76 degrees Brix
  • Best As a Corn Syrup Substitute For: Sauces and pies
  • How to Substitute Agave for Corn Syrup: Use a 1:1 ratio. Agave is sweeter and thinner than corn syrup, so cut back slightly on other sugars if a test batch runs sweet. It browns quickly, so lower the oven temperature by about 25 degrees Fahrenheit or shorten the bake time.
  • Agave Taste Profile: Clean and mild, with a faint floral note. Light agave leaves flavor and color mostly untouched in place of light corn syrup, while amber agave adds a light caramel taste.

4. Simple Syrup

a small measuring spoon full of simple syrup

Making simple syrup is also a great option if your pantry is truly looking sparse. Simple syrup usually has a 1:1 sugar-to-water ratio that calculates to 50% Brix, but you’ll want this mixture to be a lot thicker to mimic the viscosity of corn syrup. Instead, dissolve 1 cup of sugar in 1/4 cup of water to mimic corn syrup and bring the Brix level to around 80%. Since the only taste the simple syrup will bring is sweetness, you can use it for a variety of recipes like pies, sauces, and cocktails. However, do not use it for candy making!

  • 4:1 Simple Syrup Brix Level: 80 degrees Brix
  • Best As a Corn Syrup Substitute For: Drink recipes, sauces, and pies
  • How to Substitute Simple Syrup for Corn Syrup: Use a 1:1 ratio, but only with the thick 4:1 syrup (1 cup sugar to 1/4 cup water). Heat it until the sugar fully dissolves and cool it before measuring. It’s all sucrose, so it can recrystallize in storage or in sauces. A squeeze of lemon juice or a pinch of cream of tartar splits some of the sucrose and helps prevent that.
  • Simple Syrup Taste Profile: Plain sweetness with no flavor of its own, so vanilla, fruit, and spices come through cleanly. It won’t give the body and chew corn syrup does.

5. Tapioca Syrup

pouring tapioca syrup over flour in a bowl

Tapioca syrup is another useful corn syrup substitute. It’s made from the root vegetable cassava so it’s mild in flavor. It's super easy to incorporate into recipes, has the same viscosity as corn syrup, and is around the same Brix level as corn syrup. Tapioca syrup is best for use in quick bread, cakes, ice cream, sauces, and marinades.

  • Tapioca Syrup Brix Level: 78-80 degrees Brix
  • Best As a Corn Syrup Substitute For: Quick bread, cakes, ice cream, sauces, and marinades
  • How to Substitute Tapioca for Corn Syrup: Use a 1:1 ratio, ideally with a 42 DE syrup, the standard grade that matches corn syrup’s sweetness and viscosity. Lower DE syrups are thicker and less sweet, and higher DE syrups are sweeter and thinner. Tapioca syrup is also sold in bulk pails and drums, which suits high-volume prep.
  • Tapioca Taste Profile: Neutral, mildly sweet, and clear. It’s the closest match to light corn syrup, so it won’t change the taste or color of cream, vanilla, or fruit applications.

6. Honey

honey being drizzled into a white dish

Honey can be used as a corn syrup substitute, but be aware that honey’s Brix can reach up to 80%, making it a little sweeter than corn syrup. Honey also lends a more distinct taste, so remember when choosing your honey type that the lighter the honey, the lighter the flavor. Honey is not suitable for making candy or caramel because it crystallizes easily, but is great in beverages, ice cream, cheesecakes, salad dressings, marinades, and quick bread.

  • Honey Brix Level: 70-80 degrees Brix
  • Best As a Corn Syrup Substitute For: Beverages, ice cream, cheesecakes, salad dressings, marinades, and quick bread
  • How to Substitute Honey for Corn Syrup: Use a 1:1 ratio. Honey is sweeter, so trim added sugar slightly, and it browns faster, so check baked goods early or lower the oven by about 25 degrees Fahrenheit. If it crystallizes in storage, warm the container in a gentle water bath to restore it.
  • Honey Taste Profile: Floral and noticeably distinct, and it varies by source. Clover and wildflower honey are mild enough to replace light corn syrup, while buckwheat honey is dark and molasses-like, a better match for dark corn syrup.

7. Golden Syrup

refined golden sugar syrup in dish

Golden syrup is scarce in the US and more commonly found in pantries across the UK, but if you happen to have a canister of this deliciousness, use it. Golden syrup is an excellent corn syrup substitute as it can be used 1:1 for corn syrup and is ideal for candy making. However, its Brix level is a bit higher than corn syrup, so keep that in mind. Otherwise, golden syrup has a lovely caramel flavor that complements any recipe, especially treacle tarts.

  • Golden Syrup Brix Level: 82 degrees Brix
  • Best As a Corn Syrup Substitute For: Candy, marshmallows, fudge, caramels, sauces, and pies
  • How to Substitute Golden Syrup for Corn Syrup: Use a 1:1 ratio. It runs slightly sweeter than corn syrup, so taste-test sweeter items before scaling.
  • Golden Syrup Taste Profile: Buttery and caramel-like with a light toasted note. It has more flavor than light corn syrup and gives a pale amber color to pecan pie, caramel, flapjacks, and sticky toffee pudding.

8. Black Treacle

spoon dipping into a dish of black treacle

Made in the same refining process as golden syrup, black treacle makes a great corn syrup substitute, especially for dark corn syrup. While black treacle has a higher Brix level (80%), there is some pleasant bitterness in the flavor to balance out the sweetness. This other UK pantry staple is one of the main ingredients when making the British baked good sticky toffee pudding. Black treacle is technically suitable for candy making but note the significantly darker color and pronounced molasses notes.

  • Black Treacle Brix Level: 80 degrees Brix
  • Best As a Corn Syrup Substitute For: Sauces, marinades, and baked good recipes with different cinnamons and winter flavors
  • How to Substitute Black Treacle for Corn Syrup: Use it to replace dark corn syrup, but start with about half the amount and make up the rest with a milder syrup like golden syrup. Adjust from there, since a full 1:1 swap can overpower the recipe.
  • Black Treacle Taste Profile: Bittersweet and deeply molasses-like, with a toffee note. It’s a bit smoother than blackstrap molasses, and it turns batters and sauces dark brown.

Substitutes for Corn Syrup FAQ

There are a lot of questions surrounding corn syrup substitutes and when you can and can't use them. We've answered some of the most common ones below:

Corn Syrup vs High Fructose Corn Syrup

Corn syrup is made from corn starch and is almost entirely glucose. High fructose corn syrup starts the same way, but enzymes convert part of the glucose into fructose. The most common forms are HFCS 42 and HFCS 55, named for their fructose content. HFCS is used mainly in beverages and processed foods, and it’s not the corn syrup sold for baking. If you need to avoid it, check ingredient lists on pancake syrups and prepared products.

Light Corn Syrup Substitute

The best light corn syrup substitutes are golden syrup, brown rice syrup, golden or amber maple syrup, agave, tapioca syrup, simple syrup, and light honey.

Dark Corn Syrup Substitute

The best dark corn syrup substitutes are black treacle, dark maple syrup, and buckwheat honey.

Corn Syrup Substitute for Candy

The best corn syrup substitutes for candy making are brown rice syrup and golden syrup.

Corn Syrup Substitute in Baking

The best corn syrup substitutes for baking are brown rice syrup, maple syrup, agave, tapioca syrup, honey, golden syrup, and black treacle.


The right corn syrup substitute depends on what the syrup is doing in your recipe. For candy and caramel, stick with options that control crystallization, like brown rice syrup or golden syrup, while sauces, glazes, and baked goods leave more room for maple syrup, agave, honey, or tapioca syrup. Before changing a recipe across a full production run, test a small batch for texture, color, and sweetness, then write the swap and ratio on the recipe card so every cook gets the same result. If you’re making the change for a guest with a corn allergy, check the label on every syrup you use, since some pancake and table syrups contain corn syrup.

Kevin Singhel
Written by Kevin Singhel

With almost a decade of content marketing experience, Kevin has learned the ins and outs of various business sectors. Over his four years as a Longform Content Writer with WebstaurantStore, Kevin has spent hours researching and writing about the intricacies of the foodservice industry. Specializing in marketing guides, technical writing, and structured how-to content, he enjoys providing readers with content that guides them in growing and running their bar or restaurant.

Learn more about this author and WebstaurantStore's Content Writing Team here!

The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice. Please refer to our Content Policy for more details.