Pie vs Tart

Last updated on Jul 21, 2025
Kevin Singhel

Understanding the key differences between pies and tarts is essential for foodservice operators aiming to elevate their dessert menus with profitable, visually appealing pastries. While both are beloved classics, pies and tarts offer distinct textures, presentations, and preparation methods that impact ingredient selection and customer perception. Below, we directly compare crust, pan, and dough characteristics of pies and tarts, giving you the information needed to improve your kitchen efficiency and menu versatility. By mastering these nuances, you can confidently expand your offerings, market premium tart options, and drive dessert sales.

Shop All Pie Crusts and Tart Shells
Use these links to learn more about tarts and pies:

What Is a Tart?

What Is a Tart

In a commercial kitchen, tarts are characterized as a shallow, open-faced pastry renowned for their elegant presentation and refined texture. They're baked in a specialized tart pan featuring straight, vertical sides and a removable bottom, resulting in a distinct, clean-edged form ideal for showcasing high-quality fillings.

The defining tart crust, typically made from a rich, buttery pate sucree or sablee, bakes up firm, crumbly, and crisp enough to hold its shape unmolded, supporting layers like pastry cream, fresh fruit, ganache, or frangipane. The structure and sophisticated appearance of tarts make them a premium dessert choice, allowing operators to command higher price points.

Is a Tart a Pastry?

Yes, a tart is a type of pastry. They belong to the broader category of baked goods defined by a dough-based shell or casing, encompassing items like pies, quiches, croissants, and Danishes. Within professional kitchens, tarts represent a specific and versatile subset of pastries, characterized by their freestanding structure, distinct crust, and suitability for both sweet and savory applications.

Is a Tart a Pie?

No, a tart is not a type of pie. While they share the foundational concept of a pastry shell holding a filling, they belong to distinct categories within professional pastry arts due to fundamental differences in structure, preparation, and presentation. Classifying them interchangeably can lead to operational inefficiencies, such as using the wrong dough formula for a freestanding application or selecting an inappropriate pan that compromises the intended service style.

What Is a Pie?

What Is a Pie

Within foodservice operations, pies are defined as a deep-dish, often enclosed pastry. They are traditionally baked in a standard pie pan featuring gently sloped sides, designed to hold substantial amounts of both sweet fillings like spiced fruit compotes, custards, or nuts, or savory fillings such as meats, vegetables, and gravies.

The quintessential pie crust, typically a flaky pastry dough made with flour, fat, and water, provides a tender yet sturdy vessel. They often feature a bottom crust and a top crust, lattice, or crumble topping. This generous structure and familiar, homestyle character make pies ideal for high-volume service, offering strong profit margins through ingredient flexibility and crowd-pleasing recognition.

What’s the Difference Between a Tart and a Pie?

What’s the Difference Between a Tart and a Pie?

Clearly distinguishing between tarts and pies is crucial for menu planning, ingredient procurement, and efficient kitchen execution. While both are beloved baked goods, their core structures, preparation methods, and resulting customer experiences differ significantly. Understanding these key distinctions ensures you select the right pastry for your concept and accurately price items based on their value and complexity.

  • Tart Crust vs Pie Crust: A tart crust is typically rich, firm, and crumbly. They're designed to hold their shape unmolded and provide a distinct, buttery bite supporting delicate fillings. Pie crust is primarily valued for its flaky, tender layers, and handles substantial fillings, frequently requiring a top crust or lattice.
  • Tart Pan vs Pie Pan: Tarts are baked in specialized tart pans with straight, vertical sides and a removable bottom, essential for achieving the clean, professional edges needed for elegant presentation and easy release. Pies utilize standard pie pans with gently sloped sides, facilitating easier serving of deep fillings and often eliminating the need for unmolding before portioning and serving.
  • Tart Dough vs Pie Dough: Tart dough is a shorter dough, resulting in a dense, crisp texture that's often pressed into the pan for precise shaping. Pie dough is a flakier dough developed through minimal handling to create distinct layers, rolled out thinner and designed to contain both bottom and potentially top layers of filling efficiently.

Pie vs Tart FAQ

Below, we answer some of the most frequently asked questions about pies and tarts:

Pie vs Tart FAQ

Can You Make a Tart in a Pie Pan?

A pie pan's sloped sides fundamentally compromise the structural integrity needed for a classic freestanding tart, often causing the delicate crust to slump during baking or fracture upon removal attempts. In a commercial kitchen, this leads to inconsistent presentation and an end product that fails to meet the elevated visual standards expected of a tart. Investing in proper tart pans with straight sides and removable bottoms is essential for achieving the clean, stable presentation that defines this high-margin pastry category.

Can You Use Pie Crust for Tarts?

While both use flour and fat, the structural chemistry of tart dough (pate brisse, sucree, or sablee) is engineered differently than pie crust (shortcrust or puff pastry), making them non-interchangeable in professional settings. Pie crust's flaky, pliable nature lacks the structural rigidity needed for freestanding tarts, often resulting in a soggy base and uneven baking. This mismatch increases waste from unstable products and fails to deliver the crisp, sturdy foundation essential for premium fillings. For reliable results that justify higher menu pricing, dedicated tart dough formulations are a non-negotiable investment in quality and operational efficiency.

Galette vs Tart

Galettes are free form pastries where filling is placed in the middle of the crust and the sides of the dough are folded up and over the contents, providing a casual rough edge that protects the filling from spilling over. They offer a rustic alternative to tarts, prioritizing speed and flexibility over precision in commercial kitchens. Unlike tarts that require specialized pans and blind-baking, galettes have a streamlined approach ideal for high-volume settings.


Both pies and tarts serve a unique purpose in a professional kitchen, impacting everything from prep efficiency to guest satisfaction. Tarts are a great dessert option for high-impact, plated elegance, while pies serve as a classic, hearty option. Mastering both items elevates your pastry program from functional to memorable, turning every slice into a testament to your kitchen’s skill and presentation.

The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice. Please refer to our Content Policy for more details.
External Link

You are about to leave the security of WebstaurantStore.com.

We are not responsible for the privacy policy or any content, links or software, or any consequences from your access to or use of the technologies, websites, information and programs made available on this new site.

Do you want to proceed?