Other Available Flavors:

  • Approximately 100 servings per bag
  • Saves time baking from scratch
  • Must-have cookie flavor
  • Makes soft, moist cookies
Usually Ships in 1 Business Day
When will I receive my Item?
20 reviews
Package Size 5 Pounds
Type Cookie

Customer questions about this product

Do you have any tips on how I can improve the recipe on the front of the package?
Our product experts have found that adding 11 fluid ounces of water to 5 pounds of cookie mix achieves the best results.
Ask your own question!


Treat your customers to the sweet taste and aroma of warm, freshly-baked cookies made from this 5 lb. sugar cookie mix! Rather than spending time baking cookies from scratch, this mix allows you to quickly whip up batches of delicious, moist cookies to satisfy all of your patrons. In fact, each 5 lb. bag can create almost 100 cookies! Providing all of the ingredients you need, this mix just requires you to add water, mix, and bake. Simplify the baking process and serve your guests more quickly and efficiently with this sugar cookie mix!

Though these cookies are easy to make, they still retain the soft texture and a homemade taste that your patrons know and love. This Old Tyme Mill cookie mix, from National Foods Packaging, features the sweetened, classic taste of vanilla sugar cookies.These sugar cookies have a warm and comforting taste that's great for the winter season or to spruce up your menu with holiday specialty treats. Add decorative icing for enhanced presentation. Perfect for making a sweet snack or a nostalgic dessert, this versatile cookie mix is sure to delight your customers.

Sold in a 5 lb. bag.

Preparation Instructions:
Using a mixing bowl and a paddle, place cookie mix into the bowl. Start mixer on a low speed then add 11 oz. of water and allow it to mix in. Once all of the water is evenly mixed in, the dough is completed. This should take approximately 1 minute. Be careful not to over mix.
Next, form a log/snake about 1" in diameter, then cut the snake into 1 1/2" long increments (1 oz. pieces). Round the cut pieces into a ball and place onto a lightly greased baking sheet. Flatten each ball of dough slightly. This will give you a 3" - 3 1/4" finished cookie.

Conventional Oven Baking Instructions:
Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Bake for about 12-14 minutes or until golden brown. Remove cookies and place onto a cooling rack.

Convection Oven Baking Instructions:
Preheat oven to 325 degrees. Bake for about 7-9 minutes or until golden brown. Remove cookies and place onto a cooling rack.

Note: Baking times may vary depending on the oven.

Due to the density of this dry mix, it should be measured by weight, not measured out.


Kosher - Orthodox Union Certification

Related Items

Customer Reviews

Overall User Rating: 5 lb. Sugar Cookie Mix ( 4.7 stars from 20 reviews )

    I wanted to give this mix a try just because of the amazing price and the ease of mixing and baking them. They were ok. No better than your store bought sugar cookie, but not as good as the mix I was previously using. Can't win them all.

    Posted on

    I have great ideas for this cookie mix, adding some fruit filling to make thumb print cookies, decorating some with colored sugar an sprinkles, and even putting into a cookie cup pan and inserting mini peant butter cups into the centers ...this will be a real time saver too!!

    Posted on

    Surprising how good these taste. my mother is my cookie baker and has baked sugar cookies my entire life. She even liked this brand. very easy and convenient.

    from Kali Kakes Posted on

    Wow really fast just added water an mixed simple and fast. Our youth group made these for our rib dinner . Made a lot of really moist delicious cookies. Big hit

    from Paddletown St. Pauls U.M.Church Posted on

    This 5 lb cookie mix is a very good and affordable way to be able to serve our customers with home baked cookies. They love them!

    from Legends Salon Posted on

    This was my first time using sugar cookie mix it came out perfect and I use different style of cookie cutters and the taste was actually wonderful

    from Deions Treats & Sweets Posted on

    This mix makes a great base for cookies and really all you do is add water. I tend to add additional ingredients to add more flavor, so think again of it as a base.

    from Shalane Bakes Posted on

    Delicious cookies that are very easy to make, and very enjoyable to eat. Don't tell Mom, but these cookies are actually better then the ones she makes.

    Posted on

    Nice easy sugar cookies. Not good for rolled out cookies as it doesn't hold it's shape well without puffing but sprinkle a little cinnamon sugar on top and it makes a wonderful snickerdoodle.

    Posted on

    I have to say, I usually would much rather make my own cookies, but this mix is fantastic. The taste is superb and the quality is, as well. I'm just a home cook, but I would highly recommend this product to anyone who needs to make a lot of cookies at one time!! My only issue with the mix is that the bag doesn't give more directions on how much water to use. If I want to make a dozen cookies rather than 5lbs, I have to calculate out the water and inevitably it's wrong (but it doesn't affect the taste, just the density!)

    Posted on

    Not real happy with this mix. It lacks in flavor. Maybe I can add some flavorings or other ingredients to improve the taste. Probably won't order again unless I can improve it with add-ins.

    from Katy MM Posted on

    These sugar cookies came out so well. This is a very goo brand of sugar cookie mix. Not too too sweet but just right. The customer I made them for loved them!

    from Shavonna's Yummy Treats & Creations Posted on

    The 5 lb. Sugar Cookie mix .Just add water makes a fast batch of sugar cookies . They taste Great, The kids love them .We put sugar sprinkles on ours for decoration.

    Posted on

    This is a great basic sugar cookie mix for making cookies for the holidays! I love to make delicious sugar cookie bars as a unique gift item!

    Posted on

    This sugar cookie mix makes great cookies. You can use this mix for so many different types of cookies. We use them all year round and with all sorts of toppings

    Posted on

    This is such an easy product to use! It is so convenient and a great price as well. I make these plain or cover them in icing.

    Posted on

    Wow this makes a lot of cookies and they taste like they are homemade in a fraction of the time. Its great for the Holidays.

    from Cummings Family Posted on

    This mix is perfect! The cookies it yields are delicious as it, or you can add different things to make the cookies to your liking!

    Posted on

    The 5 lb. Sugar cookie Mix . Has a great tast,just ad water and bake.Everyone love's cookies.The 5 lb. Bag makes over 600 cookie's.You can sell at reasonable price and still make a profite. Thanks.

    from Harrison Familey Restaurant Posted on

Get paid to review this product!

If you've used this product, simply log in and share your text, video, and photo reviews of it. The customers on the left did it, and you can too! Earn up to $16.00 per product.

Login or Register