Quantity Discounts


Ships free with Plus
Buy 1 - 5 $13.49/Each

  • 4.5 lb. supply
  • All-natural
  • Creamy peanut butter flavor
  • Versatile ingredient or topping
  • Great for bakeries, ice cream shops, and catering

UPC Code:




Usually Ships in 1 Business Day
When will I receive my item?

Flavor Peanut Butter
Kosher Yes
Made in America Yes
Package Size 4.5 lb.
Type Peanut Butter


Packaged in a convenient 4.5 lb. jar for your back of the house needs, REESE'S® all-natural peanut butter is perfect for use as a topping or as a cooking and baking ingredient! This melt-in-your-mouth peanut butter has a smooth, finely ground texture with a creamy, full-bodied peanut butter taste. Drizzle peanut butter flavor over cheesecakes, cupcakes, brownies, bars, and more. Perfect for your ice cream parlor, bakery, or restaurant, this smooth peanut butter is a quick and easy way to enhance the appearance and taste of just about any dessert! Blend it into thick and creamy peanut butter milkshakes, or bake it into cookies and pies. Featuring simple, natural ingredients, it can even be used in cooking to make marinades and Asian-inspired peanut sauces. The 4.5 lb. plastic jar features a resealable cap to keep your product fresh, and will keep your business or catered event in good supply.

Owned by The Hershey Company, REESE'S® specializes in perfecting the decadent combination of creamy peanut butter and smooth milk chocolate. H.B. Reese created the first REESE'S® peanut butter cup in 1928, and it is now known the world over. Whichever way you use them, REESE'S® product line of peanut butter cups, baking supplies, and toppings brings freshness, great flavor, and the assurance of a beloved, recognizable brand to your business. Stock up and save with this bulk supply of all-natural peanut butter!

For best results, it is recommended to thoroughly stir this product or run it through a mixer before use. Separation of the oil from the peanut butter is natural during storage.

  • Made in America

    Made in America

    This item was made in the United States of America.

  • Orthodox Union (Dairy)

    Orthodox Union (Dairy)

    This dairy item is certified Kosher by the Orthodox Union.

Resources and Downloads

Nutrition Sheet Nutrition Hershey Certificates Certificate Kosher Certification Letter Kosher Certification

A PDF viewer is required to view this product's information. Download Adobe Acrobat software

Customer Reviews

  • Overall User Rating: REESE'S® All-Natural Peanut Butter - 4.5 lb. Jar

    4.9 stars from 30 reviews


    People Talk About:

    peanut butter great REESE'S natural taste cream ice sauce Jar

    I love the great taste and quality of the REESE'S all natural peanut butter. It is great for making our peanut butter cup milkshakes. I love the great consistency and its so easy to spread.

    from Pittman's Country Market Posted on

    When I first bought a jar of this, I had no idea that it would go as quickly as it did. I had to reorder a bunch of these peanut butter jars within a few weeks. It is delicious!

    Posted on

    With this 4.5-pound jar, there is so much Reese's all natural peanut butter goodness to use. Yes we do spread it on top of cheesecakes, ice cream and cupcakes. We also use it as ingredient to make peanut salad dressing. The consistency is just right and the taste is awesome.

    Posted on

    awesome as ingredient to salad dressing

    Reese’s all natural peanut butter. A jug that weighs 4.5 pounds! It has to be mixed well and it then can be used in many different dishes.

    Posted on

    Reese’s all natural peanut butter!

    A really nice creamy peanut butter from REESE'S that tastes great. A perfect addition to our smoothies for extra protein. The peanut butter is also great for making our peanut butter frosting.

    Posted on

    This is the most delicious peanut butter sauce. It goes perfectly in ice cream and cheesecake and in cookies and cakes. You won't find this in any store and this site has the best price to buy in bulk!

    Posted on

    This all natural reeses peanut butter is so good. It makes our smoothies very rich and creamy. We buy this product all the time. A+ product.!!

    from Be Fit Nutrition, LLC Posted on

    Perfect texture and viscosity for drizzling and dispensing. Love the option for natural peanut butter with the ease of not having to thin it out to make our drizzle. Definitely a staple in our shop!

    from Oh My Donuts Posted on

    I can't believe that I found this. Peanut butter is one of my favorite flavors and now I have something to put on vanilla ice cream

    from Foxland market Posted on

    Arrived on time and in good condition. Tastes exactly like Reese's! Arrives in an unmixed watery/ goopy mess, so plan on having an egg beater, a cake mixer, something of that sort handy to whip it up into its intended final product.

    Posted on

    Husband was so glad to see his Favorite Peanut Butter. It is so difficult to find. Remember, great Peanut Butter has oil. Stir it thoroughly.

    Posted on

    Perfect for baking (and that's all). Before we ordered, we called to make sure this was actual peanut butter and not just peanut butter sauce. When we received it, we verified that it was actual peanut butter. After mixing the ingredients together (they had separated), the peanut butter was runnier than we expected. This was perfect for us, since we were baking with it. However, if you're looking for peanut butter to use in a non-baking application, look elsewhere. I wouldn't want this on my sandwich.

    Posted on

    This peanut butter is separated when it arrives, but you just need to place it in a separate container and mix it up to get it back in a solid state. If you want to keep it in a solid state, simply refrigerate it in between uses. This is a great product for baking as we melt it down before use. Highly recommend.

    The REESE'S All-Natural Peanut Butter is delicious! I use it for ice cream topping and for shakes. I am very happy with my purchase and highly recommend!

    Posted on

    This peanut butter is delicious! Very good on ice cream. Will definitely purchase again if needed.

    I have ordered this in the past and this time got a bad one, however customer service rectified the problem within 3 minutes. Flavor warranted the fifth star!!

    Posted on

    Great flavor and texture, I use this to make my peanut butter filling and peanut butter frosting for my cakes, this is also a great value.

    Posted on

    When I originally bought this product I thought it was actual peanut butter. This products is NOT peanut butter but a peanut butter sauce. It has been excellent however in my morning protein shakes!

    Posted on

    This is just Peanut butter, not reesses filling as i thought, but still great to use in baking and sandwiches. And you get 4.5 pounds of it for a good price.

    Posted on

    It tastes like premium peanut butter. It is all natural which is an added bonus. It is a big jar but will go quickly due to great taste.

    Posted on

    Very happy with this purchase I got four and a half pounds of Reese's peanut butter from the webstaurant.com had a great deal and it's delicious

    from home Posted on

    REESE'S® All-Natural Peanut Butter - 4.5 lb. Jar #403340035024 this is a sauce not a thick peanut butter, its nice on anythingg its sweet and makes for a good dip for cookies or topped on ice cream

    from PowerQuee Media Posted on

    Great taste and great size, all for your money's worth. I highly reccomend this product and i will for sure buy again once im done with this one!

    Posted on

    Very nice product for the price. We use it for many recipes and it's a good quality compared to others at a higher price. Would recommend.

    from Just Eat This Catering Posted on

    i give it 5 stars, but want to say that I did not properly read the description. I thought I was purchasing all natural peanut butter, not a sauce for drizzling. When I discovered my error, we chose to simply sell the product as a drizzle for customers to use over dog food. The products is great tasting and a good value. My error in not reading the description should not cause me to downgrade it. I do hope the main description can be changed to read "sauce" in the bold print though.

    from The Barking Cat Posted on

    We love making homemade ice cream with our family. However we have had such a problem finding peanut butter that taste good and can be used as a sauce. This Reese's peanut butter is perfect! We love the taste it's perfect!

    from Dream Thread LLC Posted on

    I purchased the Reese's all-natural peanut butter in the 4.5 lb. jar. The large jar has a wide opening which makes it easy to scoop out with a measuring cup.

    from MIMI Posted on

    You must try this product. Not only is it delicious but this wonderful flavor in a tub gives your peanut butter cookies the best flavor. My peanut butter cookies made with it always come out chewy and tasty.

    from city girl_country cook Posted on

    I would've given this a five star review but it is very difficult to stir. I understand it is peanut butter and you have to stir in the oil but it is extraordinarily difficult to actually get it smooth especially if you leave it in the original container. The taste is very good however and it works for what I needed to but the stirring is probably the major downside of this peanut butter.

    from Small and Simple confections Posted on

    We haven't been able to find this product anywhere else. Previously, we have used actual reese's cups in our production of frozen yogurt batches, but unless you spend a lot of time getting it really creamy (no chocolate pieces), it can mess up our machine. With this peanut butter, we get the same great taste without the risk of hard pieces during the production process. If that is what you are looking for, then I definitely recommend this product for you. We have been extremely pleased with it!

    from Miller Enterprise LLC Posted on

    This peanut butter topping has been amazing when I make peanut butter balls. It tastes great, and it's very easy to use. Just give it a good shake before you use it!

    from Ashley's Baked Goods Posted on

    This stuff is amazing! I have used it on top of ice cream, and to make peanut butter cookies so far, and love it. I can't wait to try it out in some more recipes.

    Posted on

User Submitted Photos & Video:

Get paid to review this product!

If you've used this product, simply log in and share your text, video, and photo reviews of it. The customers on the left did it, and you can too! Earn up to $16.00 per product.

Login or Register

Find Related Products