Mix & Match Discounts
Quantity Discounts


Buy 1 - 3 $65.49/Case
  • Delightful taste of peanut butter
  • Velvety smooth consistency
  • Chocolate crumb crust with a thin layer of dark chocolate
  • Ready to serve out of the box
  • Chocolate drizzle icing and peanuts on top
  • Made with the highest quality ingredients
  • Ships frozen
  • Can be stored refrigerated
UPC Code: 750310063027
Shipping: Usually Ships in 2-3 Business Days
Diameter 9 Inches
Flavor Peanut Butter
Kosher Yes
Made in America Yes
Package Size 40 oz.
Type Pie

Customer questions about this product

When will my refrigerated or frozen food product be shipped?
In order to control the amount of time in transit for these perishable items, they are only shipped on select days of the week based on which shipping method you choose and the transit time to your location.

Ground: Orders ship Monday through Wednesday.
Second Day: Orders ship Monday through Wednesday.
Next Day: Orders ship Monday through Thursday.

Orders placed after the cutoff will ship the following Monday. If transit time allows for timely delivery to your location our warehouse may choose to ship some orders outside of these defined windows.

Orders placed on or just prior to a holiday could experience a slight delay in shipping.

Frozen and refrigerated items cannot ship in a quantity that requires Common Carrier shipping, as well as cannot be shipped outside of the United States.
Ask your own question!


Serve up a decadently sweet dessert with this Pellman peanut butter pie. With the delightful taste of peanut butter, this pie is the perfect dessert for any patron looking for a sweet and creamy dessert. Each peanut butter pie comes on a chocolate crumb crust with a thin layer of dark chocolate between the crust and peanut butter. Additionally, the chocolate drizzle icing and peanuts on top draw your patrons' eyes to this pie.

Best of all, this peanut butter pie is ready to serve right out of the box to save you time and money. Simply cut the pie to portion size and serve. End any dining experience with the ultimate capstone by serving this delicious pie!

Pellman uses the richest ingredients and rigorous quality control measures to create the finest ready to serve desserts. Based in the rolling hills of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, the company started right in the kitchen of the Pellman family before growing into the large business it is today. Using authentic, finely-tuned recipes, all Pellman desserts are made from scratch, without using mixes or taking shortcuts. Plus, each dessert is decorated and iced by hand to ensure an unmatched taste and appearance that will stand out against national brands. With their strict attention to quality, you can be assured that when you serve a Pellman dessert you are serving the absolute best.

  • Made in America

    Made in America

    This item was made in the United States of America.

  • Frozen Food

    Frozen Food

    This item is shipped frozen. You will need to ensure this item is stored at 0 degrees Fahrenheit or below.

  • KO Dairy Kosher

    KO Dairy Kosher

    This item is certified dairy Kosher by KO Kosher Service.

Resources and Downloads

Pellman Peanut Butter Pie nutrition Nutrition Ingredients Ingredients Brochure Brochure

A PDF viewer is required to view this product's information. Download Adobe Acrobat software

Customer Reviews

  • Overall User Rating: Pellman 9" Peanut Butter Pie - 6/Case

    5.0 stars from 5 reviews

    Several months ago, my son told me he wanted a peanut butter pie for his birthday. The only problem, he lives in South Carolina & I live in Florida. He is one of triplets, the other 2 live in my town. After reading reviews of several online shops, I decided I would order one for him through your site. There was an issue with the delivery date so your company graciously gave me a partial refund for the shipping. My son got home from work yesterday to be greeted with a package awaiting him. He had some last night & let me know that it was delicious. Thank you very much for making this birthday special for him since we will not all be able to celebrate their birthdays together.
    Oh Wow this pie is so good.. If you like peanut butter pie this is it.. its a have to buy and try pie.. Taste so good and creamy and crunchy both..its huge too... so thick you can only eat a small piece. Its really rich.. will buy this again ... loved it.
    Pellman Peanut Butter Pie is full of rich, creamy peanut butter flavor. Pair that with the sweet chocolate cookie crumb crust and you have a decadently delicious dessert that your customers will be raving about.
    The perfect treat for peanut butter fans and has a light, creamy texture. The peanut butter pie is so good and a top seller at our sweets shop.
    This pie is so popular at our shop! Such a rich and creamy peanut butter, and the crust is perfect. Not overly sweet, the absolute perfect blend of flavors. Yummy! Will be ordering again!

Leave a review of this product!

If you've used this product, log in and leave a review to tell us and other customers what you thought about it.

Login or Register

Find Related Products